Dr. Marvin Carter enlisted in the Marine Corps as a private in 1972. Fourteen years later, by then a major, he was forced out in a purge of gay and lesbian service members.

On Nov. 10, the Marine Corps' 251st birthday, Carter hosted the annual dinner of Helping Our Brothers & Sisters (HOBS), the nonprofit he founded, at Fleming's in Las Vegas. The next afternoon, Veterans Day itself, he carried the evening's themes to the Lambda Business Association luncheon.

Across both rooms, the message held. What happened to you does not have to decide who you become. And the person across the table probably shares more with you than you think.

A dinner that became a mission

HOBS began as exactly this: a dinner held every Nov. 10 to honor the Marine Corps and the gay and straight veterans who served. It gained federal 501(c)(3) status in 2008. In its Washington, D.C., years it worked as a micro-charity for marginalized LGBT people, including gay rights pioneer Frank Kameny in his final years. Since 2013, it has focused on veterans, especially LGBTQ+ veterans and those living with PTSD.

Carter's own service record explains why. A Mission Commander in covert roles who worked with the CIA and NSA, he received an other-than-honorable discharge in 1986 after acknowledging, when asked, that he was gay, according to HOBS. He still lives with PTSD, and he takes no pay for the work.

Carter introduced the evening's speakers by reading from his notes through new reading glasses. "I just had cataract surgery," he told the room. "I used to be nearsighted. Now I'm farsighted."

Twenty years to the day

David Shoup, a Marine infantry combat veteran, attorney and author of the bestseller *Mission Freedom*, said he did not need a microphone. He was right.

Shoup took the room back exactly 20 years, to a cold, dark night in Iraq. From a sandbagged position behind a .50-caliber machine gun, he was the "guardian angel" for a post of Iraqi soldiers 800 meters down the road. A sniper opened fire on them. Shoup radioed for permission to return fire, but he could not see the shooter.

"I had to sit there and watch every single soldier that was in my care shot and killed by that sniper," he said, "and I had not fired a single round."

For 15 years, that night defined him. Shoup described nightly flashbacks, two stays at a VA hospital and half a dozen medications. He said he "adopted that failure into my very essence" and made it his identity, until he reached what he called the edge.

Then he looked at it differently. A .50-caliber round can tear through four to six buildings. Had he fired blind, he said, he would have killed dozens of Iraqi civilians who had nothing to do with the fight. By holding fire, he had accomplished his mission. The source of his nightmares became a source of pride.

"Pain will happen in your life. It's called being human," Shoup said. "Suffering is a choice."

He left the room with three questions. What is really influencing your life right now? What meaning have you given it? And what better belief can you choose to live by instead?

Shoup also spoke directly to the LGBTQ+ veterans in the room. "Military service for some of you meant hiding who you really were," he said. "It meant living with fear of being discovered, facing discrimination and rejection, and even being discharged for who you were. Your service was no less honorable, your sacrifices were no less real, and your wounds are no less worthy of recognition."

He now works with veterans, first responders and their families through the Warriors Awakening Foundation, and said the group is working to get onto military bases to help active-duty troops avoid PTSD in the first place.

"All veterans are served"

Col. Mary L. Devine, director of the Nevada Department of Veterans Services, missed last year's dinner after a medical emergency at a San Diego conference. "I just don't recommend leaving the conference by ambulance with like 15 paramedics," she said. This year she made it, joined by Mark Prizina, NDVS interim deputy director of benefits.

Gov. Joe Lombardo appointed Devine in March 2024, making her the department's 17th director since 1943. She came from a 36-year career in the Nevada Army National Guard, most recently as chief of staff to the adjutant general. Carter said he was among the first people she met with when she came south, over lunch at the same restaurant.

Devine laid out how the department has grown. When she arrived, NDVS had 23 veteran service officers; by year's end it will have about 60. It has gone from three grants worth roughly $300,000 to seven worth about $5.5 million. A $1.3 million share of the state's rural health transformation funding will add service officers and navigators in rural Nevada, adult day health care in Elko and newborn supply boxes for rural veteran families.

For this audience, she singled out one service. "We have a responsibility at the Department of Veterans Services to make sure that all veterans are served," Devine said. "That goes for discharge upgrades." She called HOBS's population "underserved" and said the department is "here to answer the call" for anyone seeking help with a discharge or benefits.

She also announced an online platform, expected within 90 days, that will let veterans find federal, state and nonprofit benefits on their own devices.

Carter returned the praise. Of the directors he has known since Caleb Cage, he said, Devine has "really reached out" and expanded the department.

Finding common ground

At the Lambda luncheon on Veterans Day, Carter told his own story. In the late 1970s, his plane went down in the desert of Djibouti, in the Horn of Africa. Rebel forces held him for almost a year before the French Foreign Legion freed him. Many details remain classified.

He placed it in a brief history of how captors have treated prisoners, from ancient slavery to the Geneva Conventions. He also noted the black-and-white POW/MIA flag, championed by Navy wife Mary Hoff after her husband went missing in 1970. "I did come home," Carter said. "Sadly, not everybody does."

His real subject was finding common ground. It does not mean agreeing on everything, he said, or giving up principles, or one side winning. It means looking past differences long enough to see what we share: safety for our families, opportunity for our children, a decent living and dignity.

His advice was practical. Instead of asking someone why they believe what they believe, ask what they are trying to accomplish. Often, he said, the goals turn out to be the same. "Ask yourself, do I want to win this argument, or do I want to solve the problem?"

Carter illustrated it with a dinner in a village near Osan, South Korea, where he traveled monthly for two years. His Navy linguist had invited him home, and the dirt roads were lined with villagers who had come to see the guest. His host's wife had spent a month's local wages on the meal. "That night, kimchi became my friend," he said.

He also looked back to the night before. LGBTQ+ rights have come a long way, he said, with a long way still to go. The dinner, he added, reminded LGBTQ+ people, especially transgender people in today's climate, that resources exist and people are working on their behalf.

"You can disagree without hatred," Carter said. "You can stand firm without being cruel. You can defend principles without attacking somebody's humanity."

Two days, one message

Shoup's message and Carter's run along the same line. One man reframed a night in Iraq; the other was pushed out of the service he gave 14 years to. Both chose what those experiences would mean.

Carter closed the luncheon with the country itself. "America has never been a nation where everyone agreed," he said. "Our strength comes not from eliminating those differences, but learning how to live with them and finding common ground to move forward."